home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT1200>
- <title>
- Sep. 05, 1994: Society:Down and Out in Telluride
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Sep. 05, 1994 Ready to Talk Now?:Castro
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- SOCIETY, Page 60
- Down and Out In Telluride
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> In America's tourist boomtowns, low wages and high rents are
- leaving the working class out in the cold
- </p>
- <p>By Gregory Jaynes--Reported by Richard Woodbury/Telluride
- </p>
- <p> Don't take it personally. Your restaurant manners were impeccable;
- your gratuity was generous to a fault. Then why did the waitress
- sneer at you, and why were the waiters so ill tempered? In fact,
- what was it with all the snarly help, all the way along your
- Rocky Mountain holiday this summer? They couldn't all have got
- out of bed on the wrong side, could they? No. That would assume
- they all had beds. On the contrary, many of these people, out
- of necessity, were sleeping in dirt. It would put you in a bad
- mood too.
- </p>
- <p> "Most of my friends used to live in homes," says a woman who
- lives in a tent. "Now they're camping." This was outside Telluride,
- the too-precious-for-words old Colorado mining gem that perches
- way up there in the San Juan Range like a jay's nest in a ponderosa
- pine. The woman, Jill Mattioli, 28, used to have an apartment
- in town--back when she could afford it. Now she lives off
- in the woods near others who service Telluride in manifold ways
- but whose purchasing power is so weak they sleep in their cars,
- in campers, in condemned shacks, in caves, in tents. "If I wait
- and serve these people," says Mattioli, who has lately been
- mowing lawns, "I should be able to live here and have a decent
- standard of living."
- </p>
- <p> She is wrong. A 40-hour workweek, even at double the minimum
- wage of $4.25 an hour, does not necessarily buy you shelter
- anymore--especially in America's tourist boomtowns. Life for
- the working class in resort areas has always been short on personal
- amenities, but the situation is now reaching crisis proportions
- because of stagnating wages and escalating real estate prices.
- From snow-and-arts resorts like Breckenridge, Colorado, to country-music
- Meccas like Branson, Missouri, America's playlands are producing
- a booming class of unfortunates: the hardworking homeless. To
- step off the main drag of a glistening little jewel like Telluride,
- then, is like stepping out the back flap of a circus tent: Lord,
- there's a caravansary of gypsies parked back here! The chief
- of Telluride's housing authority, Dave Johnson, quit in June,
- citing job stress. The problem, says Jim Davidson, editor of
- the Telluride Times-Journal, "brings instability and a surly
- work force. We can't expect nice worker attitudes when people
- come to work begging a shower."
- </p>
- <p> The situation in tourist towns is an extreme version of the
- trend that affects the rest of America--the dearth of working-class
- jobs that pay enough to support a life with even the bare necessities.
- Much of the job growth in the boomtowns is in the so-called
- hospitality business, where workers typically start as waiters,
- maids and bartenders at about $6 an hour. In the five counties
- that account for most Colorado tourism, 45% of all births in
- 1992 were to low-income families, according to local health
- departments. In Pitkin County, where Aspen is situated, the
- number of births to families on Medicaid quadrupled--to 16%--in the three years ending in 1992.
- </p>
- <p> Most of these towns have grown up in rural areas where nobody
- thought much about a working population that needed public transportation,
- day care and other amenities. Most critical is the housing crisis
- from bauble to municipal bauble along the glittery necklace
- of Rocky Mountain resorts. Here, each square foot of real estate
- today fetches a ransom. Gone to outrageously priced condos are
- the apartments the help used to rent--and there is scant room
- left to build more. The reason is location, location, location:
- these picturesque hamlets beckon and charm and cost the earth
- because they are usually isolated and they often cannot grow,
- surrounded--especially in the Rockies--by federal lands
- that are vertical. And where the private land flattens out sufficiently,
- the people with bulging purses are putting up $1 million log
- cabins. So the help either commutes from a distance out by where
- the sun sets or sleeps nearby, under stars.
- </p>
- <p> Take tiny Telluride, 2 1/2 miles square, whose population of
- 1,500 grows to 6,000 in the skiing months. Basically, $300,000
- buys you four walls exceedingly close together. Bank president
- William Dodge laments, "It's a struggle to live here with three
- kids. If my wife didn't work, we probably couldn't." Together,
- the Dodges make about $200,000 a year.
- </p>
- <p> In a tepee by a creek 35 minutes down valley from town lives
- a 25-year-old woman who works the counter in a local coffee
- shop. Monique Toulouse says she has her name--she says it
- is her name--on a waiting list for one of the 108 housing-authority
- apartments in the city ($450 a month for a one-bedroom), but
- her position on the document is more than a year down from the
- top. Before winter, she declares, knowing that it is a foolish
- declaration, "I'm determined to find a $250 rental." Kevin Buckanaga,
- a server in a coffee shop, was happy to be subleasing a shed
- for $65 a month until he was evicted last month. He now lives
- in a tent three miles outside town.
- </p>
- <p> So why stick around? "This is God's land," says 26-year-old
- John Korte, who lives in a little pickup he parks here and there.
- Harold Wondsel lives in an old bus and Bill Pinkard in a mountainside
- lean-to and Rusty Scott in a condemned mining shack with four
- buddies--no locks, no heat, cold water, expecting an eviction
- notice, in case he was getting comfortable (he heard the property
- has been sold for half a million). "There's no concept of the
- pain we go through," said Scott, a counterman who made it through
- -40 degrees F nights in a sleeping bag last year. "The town doesn't
- realize that the people who do their dishes and clean up after
- them have to live someplace too."
- </p>
- <p> But the town does; up and down the Rockies you find municipalities
- struggling with the problem. Telluride's San Miguel County requires
- developers to set aside 15% of their sites for affordable housing.
- In Aspen, where resistance to more new "monster homes" has great
- zeal, there is a proposal to raise the amount of new development
- that must go for modest housing from 40% to 60%. In Jackson
- Hole, Wyoming, where a 14,000-sq.-ft., three-bedroom log cabin
- is going up, building inspector Dennis Johnson says a campground
- for low-wage earners might not be a bad idea.
- </p>
- <p> There are tiresome local arguments about which way to approach
- the problem. One of them is how to sort out the workers who
- can't afford shelter from the freeloaders who live dirty and
- like it. Then there is the libertarian case: Jesus was a hippie,
- man. But for the most part community leaders would like to get
- everyone back indoors, particularly when it's nasty outside.
- Of course the sorehead view is widespread too. As Jackson Hole
- builder Jacques Sarthou sees it, "You don't go into Beverly
- Hills and demand cheap housing just because you want to live
- there. If you cannot afford it, tough luck." But Beverly Hills
- is spang in the middle of one of America's largest urban bowls,
- Mr. Sarthou. It doesn't have to share with the majestic Grand
- Tetons, which don't leave a town much room.
- </p>
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-